Aluminum 6061-T6 vs. 6061-T651: Compare Their Differences

What is Al 6061 and Its Tempers?

Let us begin with a brief introduction to Al 6061 and its various tempers (grades). Al 6061 represents a group of aluminum alloys with magnesium and silicon additives, which give it its characteristic properties.

In addition, there are several tempers of Al 6061. These tempers differ in terms of heat treatment and other material conditioning techniques. Consequently, they also have different performance characteristics. Each temper has its designation as defined by standards such as ANSI H35.1/H35.1(M).

Aluminum alloy 6061-T651 and Aluminum alloy 6061-T6 are two common tempers of Al 6061. Now that we have an understanding of Al 6061 and its tempers, let us get into our debate about aluminum 6061 T6 vs T651.

Aluminum 6061-T6

Aluminum 6061-T6 is arguably the more common grade among aluminum 6061 T6 vs T651. Its fabrication process compresses three main procedures:

• Solution Heat Treatment: Aluminum, along with its specific mixture of alloying elements, is heated to a temperature of approximately 550℃ for a certain time. This forms a homogenous solution of the alloying elements in the aluminum metal matrix.
• Quenching: The hot solution is then cooled down to room temperature at a very rapid rate. This ‘freezes’ the homogenous state of the solution, preventing any particulates from precipitating/aging during the cool-down period. Generally, the quenching media is water.
• Aging: In this step, the machine shop again heats the material to a temperature of around ~1770C for hours (often 6-10 hours). This aging process allows a very controlled and stable precipitation of alloying elements in the aluminum matrix, which leads to higher hardness and toughness. In the end, a very gradual cooling brings the material back to room temperature.

Pros and Cons of Al 6061-T6

Al 6061-T6 is known for its excellent tensile strength (~290 MPa), resistance to corrosion, and high thermal conductivity. It performs well for high-performance applications like aerospace structural components or automotive chassis frames.

At the same time, it has some disadvantages as well. For example, it carries some residual stress due to its quenching cycle, as we will discuss shortly. Moreover, although compatibility with welding techniques like MIG and TIG is one of its strong points, there is a risk of quality deterioration in the heat-affected zone.

Aluminum 6061-T651

Aluminum alloy 6061-T651 is of a very similar grade to the Al 6061-T6, with slight differences in fabrication process, material characteristics, and applications. In fact, it has only one extra process in its heat treatment cycle. Let us take a look at its fabrication method from the lens of Al 6061-T651 vs 6061-T6.

• Solution Heat Treatment: The same as Al 6061-T6.
• Quenching: The same as Al 6061-T6.
• Stretching: The material is stretched using special machines from 1-3%, both towards the end of the quenching phase and after it. This relieves internal stress that builds up during solution heating and quenching.
• Aging: The same as Al 6061-T6.

It is clear that the only difference between the 6061 T6 and 6061 T651 grades is the extra step of stretching during fabrication. Although a minute difference, it leads to some obvious differences in terms of performance.

Pros and Cons of Al 6061-T651

Stretching the material de-stresses it, which helps it retain its shape and material properties better than the T6 temper. Therefore, Al 6061-T651 is slightly more dimensionally stable, weldable, and machinable than its counterpart Al 6061-T6.

It is, however, more costly and time-consuming to make due to the additional processing. Moreover, it does not bring many outstanding benefits to the table in comparison to Al 6061-T6 and is useful in very specific applications. Consequently, research is required to source it from markets and use it in a financially viable manner.

Al 6061-T651 vs Al 6061-T6

With a better understanding of the difference between 6061 T6 and 6061 T651, we can now move on to some of the specifics of our discussion on aluminum 6061 T6 vs T651.

Machinability

Aluminum machining is a large industry that serves important industries like marine, aerospace, mold and dies, and automotive. When it comes to 6061-T651 vs 6061-T6, there are notable differences in terms of performance.

Al 6061-T6 is generally an easy-to-machine material but since it carries residual stresses from solution heating and quenching, it is susceptible to issues like warping or distortion under intense machining conditions.

Aluminum alloy 6061-T651, on the other hand, has superior performance due to lower residual stresses. It can resist permanent deformations under machining forces better and conduct heat slightly more efficiently from the machining area. Due to this, manufacturers prefer the T651 temper over the T6 grade for higher precision and aluminum surface finish in machining.

Dimensional Stability

Dimensional stability differs slightly between 6061 T6 and T651 due to their respective heat treatment processes. Both alloys undergo solution heat treatment and quenching, but T651 is subjected to a stress-relieving stretching process after quenching. This reduces residual stresses within the material. In contrast, 6061 T6 may exhibit slightly higher internal stresses, which can lead to dimensional changes, especially when machining large or thin-walled parts.

Key Differences

The contrast between aluminum 6061 T6 vs T651 is not stark, but very subtle in numerous ways. In this section, we will present the difference between 6061 T6 and 6061 T651 in a clear and concise manner to help decision-makers save time and effort.

Other Tempers of Al 6061

Aluminum 6061 is a versatile alloy with a wide range of applications. While our focus is on aluminum alloy 6061-T651 and aluminum alloy 6061-T651, it is good to also take a look at some of the other tempers of Al 6061.